Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria: Authentic Italian Dining in Madison, NJ

Really great experience for a sit down dinner! Waitress was very attentive, accurate, and the food was insanely good. Great portion sizes, food was well prepared, extremely flavorful, just an all around great time!

I have been a few times in the past enjoying their pizza. We decided to eat there on Father's day & what a treat it was. Great food, wonderful friendly service in a very cool setting what more could you ask for. Everything we tried was awesome, the fried calamari & the artichoke milinase apps were delicious. The pasta entrees were huge, you can easily split one between 2 or 3 people. I had the spaghetti and red clamp sauce , it was one of the best I've had. My Granddaughter's kids spaghetti & meatballs was thoroughly enjoyed. In other words we loved it here!

Consistently one of my favorites and definitely my go to pizza spot in the area. Thin, crispy & delicious. The calzone is also A+. If you aren’t craving pizza, they have fresh salads with very good protein options. The staff at the counter is always super friendly as well.

Great experience here yesterday. We arrived as soon as it opened for lunch. The new owner was wonderful. We had pizza and I asked her recommendation...she suggested the grandma pizza which was outstanding. My son had pepperoni. Delicious! Food and hospitality were fantastic!

I wish I could give this place more than 5 stars! From start to finish our experience at Nicky's was amazing. The new owners, Amanda and Joe, have elevated and improved the decor, the pizza and the menu. We learned that Joe is a chef with many years of restaurant experience and he redid all the menu items. Amanda is the friendliest human on earth... we even heard her talking to the table of teenage girls next to us and making sure they had a ride home (it was after 9pm). The manager, Jeremy, stopped by several times to check on us and was attentive to all of our needs. The food was out of this world! We got appetizers to share and it was fresh and delicious. The rice balls were crispy on the outside, and perfectly soft and cheesy inside. They came with a delicious meat-sauce. The artichokes Milanese were perfection. Lightly breaded, crispy and delicious. They were paired with a lemon sauce. The fried zucchini was fantastic. A different spin with a thicker cut, but breaded with panko breadcrumbs and a lemon aioli dipping sauce that was unreal. You have to try this place! It's also BYOB which helps keep it budget friendly. Thank you Joe, Amanda and Jeremy for a great night out! We'll be back!

Nicky’s Firehouse in Madison is a fantastic spot for a casual meal with friends or family. The service is consistently excellent, and the food is just as good. It's BYOB, which is always a plus. We particularly enjoy their pizzas, which we always order well-done—perfectly crispy and flavorful. Their salads are fresh and hearty, and the pasta dishes never disappoint. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, Nicky's is a go-to option in town. Highly recommend!

I threw a dinner party here on a Monday night. It was family style for 16 people. The food and service were excellent and everyone really enjoyed it. I highly recommend the veal Francese, chicken parm, and eggplant Rotellini, but you really can't go wrong with anything here.